$7 OFF – The Brotherhood Cheese Assortment Pack (8 Cheeses)

Deal No Expires
$7 OFF - The Brotherhood Cheese Assortment Pack (8 Cheeses)
See Your Deal
100% Success

$7 OFF – Wisconsin Cheese Curds Sampler (8-Pack)

Deal No Expires
$7 OFF - Wisconsin Cheese Curds Sampler (8-Pack)
See Your Deal
100% Success

$7 OFF – Wisconsin Cheese of the Month Club

Deal No Expires
$7 OFF - Wisconsin Cheese of the Month Club
See Your Deal
100% Success

17% OFF – 250th USA Anniversary Americana Gift Tin

Deal No Expires
17% OFF - 250th USA Anniversary Americana Gift Tin
See Your Deal
100% Success

$11.5 OFF – Ultimate Wisconsin Cheese Sampler Box

Deal No Expires
$11.5 OFF - Ultimate Wisconsin Cheese Sampler Box
See Your Deal
100% Success

Cheese Brothers Review 2026: Wisconsin Artisan Cheese Delivered Nationwide Since 1919

Reviewed by Ark 7 · Published 04/29/2026 · Last updated 05/02/2026

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission when you purchase through our links at no additional cost to you.

Quick Summary

Best For
Cheese enthusiasts, gift buyers, and households seeking artisan Wisconsin cheese shipped nationwide — including a limited-edition 250th USA Anniversary Americana Gift Tin available for preorder.
Not Ideal For
Shoppers needing same-day pickup, those on per-ounce grocery budgets, or buyers who want cheese without any prep or pairing.
Key Advantage
Co-founded by Eric and Gene in Almena, WI, with a cheesemaking tradition tracing to 1919; a no-questions-asked satisfaction guarantee on every shipment; and free cold-pack shipping when temperatures exceed 60°F at the delivery address.
Price Range
Individual cuts from $8.95 (cheese curds); gift bundles and assortment packs $62.95–$105.95; the 250th Anniversary Americana Gift Tin $99.95 (regularly $120.00). Cheese of the Month Club subscription available.
Deal Status
We’ve handpicked the most relevant active deals for you above — simply click to apply.

About Cheese Brothers

Cheese Brothers was co-founded by Eric and Gene — two Wisconsin natives whose craft traces to a tradition beginning in 1919. Based at 1627 6th St, Almena, WI, the brand ships artisan Wisconsin cheese nationwide with free cold-pack protection when delivery temperatures exceed 60°F. The lineup spans individual cuts ($8.95–$16.00), curated gift packs ($62.95–$105.95), limited-edition tins, a Cheese of the Month Club subscription, and wholesale via faire.com. Every shipment is backed by a full satisfaction guarantee: refund or reship, no questions asked.

Pros
Named co-founders (Eric and Gene), a physical Almena, WI address, and a cheesemaking tradition since 1919 establish a level of transparency uncommon in the artisan DTC food space.
No-questions-asked satisfaction guarantee on every shipment — refund or reship — reduces risk on perishable orders sent to a new address or given as gifts.
Free cold-pack shipping with ice packs at no extra charge when delivery destination temperatures exceed 60°F — a meaningful logistics commitment for a cheese brand shipping nationwide.
Broad price range ($8.95 to $105.95) and thousands of verified on-site reviews across the most popular SKUs give buyers solid data points before purchasing.
Cons
No independent review aggregator profiles confirmed on Trustpilot, BBB, or Sitejabber — consumer sentiment data comes from brand-hosted reviews rather than external platforms.
Premium pricing compared to grocery store cheese; a single-serve artisan cut starts at $8.95 and gift boxes range from $62.95–$105.95, which may not suit budget-focused buyers.
Online-only purchasing with no retail pickup; cheese is perishable, so buyers in very remote areas or during postal delays should factor transit conditions into their planning.

⚖️ Worth-it Check

Is This 17% Deal Worth It?

17%
Baseline savings · Stack-ready
Combine with steps below to push past the floor.

The 17% discount applies specifically to the 250th USA Anniversary Americana Gift Tin — a limited-edition collector product with a regular price of $120.00 and a current sale price of $99.95. Applied to the regular price, 17% represents approximately $20 in savings. Because the tin is already showing a sale price on the brand’s site, buyers should confirm at checkout whether the promo code delivers an additional reduction on top of $99.95 or aligns with the existing markdown. Either way, a $20+ saving on a limited-edition preorder tin that ships for Father’s Day (June 15–20) or 4th of July is a competitive entry for the gifting category — particularly given Cheese Brothers’ no-questions-asked satisfaction guarantee.

🪜 The stack

How to Save More on Cheese Brothers

+1
Confirm how the 17% code applies at checkout

The 250th Anniversary Americana Gift Tin is currently showing $99.95 (from $120). Enter the promo code in the discount field and verify whether it applies to the current sale price or the regular $120.00 — the final total will tell you exactly how much you’re saving before payment.
+2
Check the preorder delivery window before ordering

The Tin ships June 15–20 for Father’s Day; a 4th of July delivery window may have different terms. Confirm the correct variant and ship date on the product page to ensure it arrives for your intended occasion.
+3
Join the “Brotherhood” email list for future exclusive deals

The brand’s newsletter prompt on the homepage offers early access to new releases and exclusive offers — useful for staying ahead of limited-edition drops and seasonal sales beyond the current preorder window.
Pro Tip

Cheese Brothers runs a Rewards program and a Cheese of the Month Club subscription — if you plan to reorder regularly, enrolling in the club or activating Rewards points on this initial Tin purchase gives you a head start on future savings without requiring an additional promo code.

Frequently Asked Questions

1

What is the 250th USA Anniversary Americana Gift Tin and when does it ship?

The 250th USA Anniversary Americana Gift Tin is a limited-edition Cheese Brothers collector product priced at $99.95 (regularly $120.00), currently available as a preorder. It ships June 15–20 for Father’s Day delivery and is also positioned as a 4th of July gift option. Full contents are detailed on the product page at cheesebros.com. Because it’s a preorder with a fixed ship window, buyers should place orders well in advance of the delivery date they need.

2

What is the best Cheese Brothers product for a first-time buyer?

The Brotherhood Cheese Assortment Pack (8 cheeses, $62.95, 749 on-site reviews) is the most-reviewed starting point and gives a broad cross-section of the Wisconsin artisan lineup. The Ultimate Wisconsin Cheese Sampler ($105.95, 560 reviews) is the step-up option for a more comprehensive first experience. For a lower-commitment entry, the Wisconsin Cheese Curds ($8.95, ships fresh daily) let you trial the brand’s quality before committing to a larger gift box.

3

How does Cheese Brothers handle shipping for perishable cheese?

Vacuum-sealed, firm cheeses are safe in transit without refrigeration under normal conditions. When temperatures at the delivery address exceed 60°F, Cheese Brothers adds cold-pack insulation and ice packs at no extra charge. The brand also monitors weather conditions to time shipments appropriately. If there’s any issue with delivery or product quality, the no-questions-asked guarantee means you can request a refund or reship by contacting [email protected] or calling 715-226-9124.

4

Does Cheese Brothers offer a subscription or loyalty program?

Yes — the Cheese of the Month Club subscription delivers curated Wisconsin cheese selections on a recurring schedule. A Rewards program is also available, allowing you to accumulate points on purchases for use toward future orders. Wholesale buyers can source through the brand’s Faire storefront. All subscription and rewards terms are managed through your account at cheesebros.com.

FAQ Coupons

1

Does Cheese Brothers have any coupon codes right now?

Yes, Cheese Brothers currently offers a verified deal delivering 17% off the 250th USA Anniversary Americana Gift Tin — a limited-edition preorder product priced at $99.95 (regularly $120.00). We verify all codes before listing them.

2

How do I use a Cheese Brothers promo code at checkout?

Add the 250th Anniversary Americana Gift Tin to your cart, proceed to checkout, and enter the code in the promo or discount code field. Confirm the 17% reduction is reflected in your order total before completing payment — and note whether it applies to the current sale price or the regular $120 retail price.

3

What is the best Cheese Brothers discount available today?

The best verified offer right now is 17% off the 250th USA Anniversary Americana Gift Tin — a limited-edition preorder shipping June 15–20 for Father’s Day. The brand is also running a Mother’s Day storewide sale of up to 20% off select gifts; check the Gifts & Packs section for currently eligible items.

4

Why isn’t my Cheese Brothers code working?

The 17% code is specific to the 250th Anniversary Americana Gift Tin. Confirm the correct product is in your cart. If the code still doesn’t apply, contact the Cheese Brothers team at [email protected] or 715-226-9124 for assistance.

5

Can I stack multiple Cheese Brothers promo codes?

Typically one promo code is accepted per order. Use the 17% code on the Americana Gift Tin as your primary discount, and verify at checkout whether it stacks with any active sitewide sale pricing.

6

How much can I save with Cheese Brothers deals?

The verified 17% offer on the 250th Anniversary Tin delivers approximately $20 in savings against the regular $120 price. The brand also runs seasonal storewide sales — currently up to 20% off Mother’s Day gifts — which apply to a broader range of products.

7

Are Cheese Brothers discount codes safe to use?

Yes. All codes listed on our site are manually verified and sourced from Cheese Brothers directly or confirmed affiliate partners. We do not publish expired or unverified codes.

Methodology

This review draws on Cheese Brothers’ official site, product catalog, pricing, About page, and shipping and guarantee policies at cheesebros.com. On-site review counts were verified per product listing. No hands-on testing was conducted.

Editorial Note

Cheese Brothers’ named founders, century-long tradition, published address, and no-questions-asked satisfaction guarantee provide a strong accountability framework for a specialty food DTC brand. No independent review aggregator profiles were confirmed on Trustpilot or Sitejabber — consumer sentiment relies on brand-hosted on-site reviews. The 250th Anniversary Tin is a preorder product with a fixed ship window; buyers with firm delivery deadlines should place orders well ahead of the June 15–20 dispatch date.

Disclaimer: This review is informational only and does not constitute professional advice. Verify current prices, preorder availability, and delivery windows directly with Cheese Brothers at cheesebros.com before purchasing.

Daily Deal Here · Coupon Codes And Deal For You · Est. 2025